B.T.K.

Kane Hodder

Dennis Rader

Amy Lyndon

Susan Rader

Odessa Rae

Heather

Cara Sigmund

Annette

Caia Coley

Mary Ann

Sarah Shoup

Lizzy

Nino Simone

Ricky

Kelsey McCann

Kelsey

John Burke

Detective Lutz

Dru Ashcroft

Sharon

Anna Margaret

Sarah

Lily Mae Silverstein

Lilly Riding

Daniel Bonjour

Detective Carmichael

Pascale Gigon

Mrs. Emerson (Teddy's Mom)

Wesley Stiller

Officer Corman

Bob Arnold

Pastor Joe